Timespreads: backwardation, contango and the crude curve
Flat price is what everyone watches. The curve is what the physical market pays. A prompt barrel priced over a deferred one means somebody needs oil now. Spreads move first because the people who handle barrels trade them.
Curve shape
- Backwardation. Prompt over deferred. The market pays you to deliver now. Stocks are drawing, and holders sell inventory into the premium. Tight market.
- Contango. Deferred over prompt. The market pays you to store. Stocks are building. Loose market.
A timespread is one month minus a later month. Positive means backwardation, negative means contango. M1/M2 is front against second month. Calendar spreads like Dec/Jan or Jan/Mar are the same thing on named months.
Cost of carry
Contango has a floor set by storage. If the curve pays more than the cost of renting tanks plus financing, traders buy prompt, store, and sell forward. That cash-and-carry trade lifts prompt, depresses deferred, and caps the contango. When the curve hits full carry, the market is telling you storage is the marginal buyer of crude. That's a glut.
Backwardation has no ceiling. If refiners need barrels and stocks are near minimum, the prompt premium goes as far as it needs to. That's why squeezes are violent and contango is slow.
Why spreads lead flat price
Flat price carries everyone: macro funds, CTAs, options hedgers, headline traders. Spreads mostly carry people who hold or need physical barrels: refiners, producers, storage owners, physical traders. When the two disagree, the spread is usually right.
- Flat price up, spreads firming. Real tightness. The rally has the physical market behind it.
- Flat price up, spreads flat or weaker. Paper rally. Positioning, headlines, macro. No physical bid underneath. Fades.
- Flat price down, spreads holding. Physical market refusing to follow. Selling is speculative. Watch for reversal.
- Flat price down, spreads collapsing. Barrels are long. The sell-off has a reason.
Which spreads
Different points on the curve answer different questions.
- Prompt spreads (M1/M2, M2/M3). This month's physical balance. Fast, noisy, distorted near expiry.
- Winter spreads (Dec/Jan, Jan/Mar). The read on how tight the market expects the next quarter to be. Less noise. Most of the drivers sections in the notes lean on these.
- Year-out spreads (Dec/Dec). The structural balance. Moves slowly. When it flips sign, the market's medium-term view has changed.
The curve can also kink: prompt backwardated, deferred in contango. That's a near-term squeeze in a market expected to loosen later. It's common around supply shocks.
The expiry trap
NYMEX WTI is physically delivered at Cushing. In the last days before expiry, the front spread trades on who is short barrels they can't deliver and who is long without tank space. Those moves can be huge and say nothing about the wider market.
ICE Brent is cash-settled, so it doesn't have the same delivery squeeze. But it expires around three weeks earlier than the same-named WTI contract, so a "Jan" Brent and a "Jan" WTI are not the same delivery period.
The notes strip front-month expiry moves out and read the next spread instead. If M1/M2 explodes in the last three sessions and M2/M3 doesn't move, nothing happened.
Cushing and WTI spreads
WTI spreads are a Cushing story. The hub has a working capacity and an operational floor below which tanks can't run. As stocks fall toward that floor, prompt WTI spreads get steeper and more nervous, because there's less buffer for any disruption. As Cushing fills, contango widens toward full carry.
Track Cushing in the EIA weekly alongside the WTI spreads. Low stocks and firming spreads is the setup for squeezes. High stocks and weakening spreads is the setup for capitulation.
The reads used here
- Spreads moving in the same direction as cracks confirm a physical move. Divergence is a warning.
- Brent spreads firming faster than WTI points to seaborne tightness. See Brent–WTI.
- Spreads firming while managed money is short is the setup for a squeeze. See positioning.
- A flat-price breakout through a key volume level means more if the spreads broke first.
The data used here
Timespreads are read from NYMEX WTI and ICE Brent futures settlements. Since 16th November 2026 the notes quote them in dollars from settlements, with the change from the previous settlement. Notes before that date described them in words and percentages only.